HD DVD
Recommended
4 stars
Overall Grade
4 stars

(click linked text below to jump to related section of the review)

The Movie Itself
3.5 Stars
HD Video Quality
3.5 Stars
HD Audio Quality
3 Stars
Supplements
3.5 Stars
High-Def Extras
4 Stars
Bottom Line
Recommended

Heroes: Season One

Street Date:
August 28th, 2007
Reviewed by:
Peter Bracke
Review Date: 1
August 22nd, 2007
Movie Release Year:
2007
Studio:
Universal Studios Home Entertainment
Length:
1009 Minutes
MPAA Rating:
Unrated
Release Country
United States

Editor's Notes

Non-format specific portions of this review also appear in our Blu-ray review of 'Heroes: Season One.'

The Movie Itself: Our Reviewer's Take

Superheroes on the small screen have been, almost without exception, a recipe for campy disaster. Sure, I still get a nostalgic kick out of watching old re-runs of such childhood favorites as 'Wonder Woman,' 'The Amazing Spider-Man' and the immortal '60s version of 'Batman,' but let's face it -- those shows are pretty dang cheesy. Aside from the (arguably) efficient if tween-oriented 'Smallville,' has there ever been a truly great, kick-ass comic book series on television?

Say hello to 'Heroes.' Ten ordinary people who are about to discover they have newfound extraordinary powers. There's Matt Parkman (Greg Grunberg), a Los Angeles police officer with the ability to hear other people's thoughts. Isaac Mendez (Santiago Cabrera), a New York artist who can "paint" future events during precognitive trances. Claire Bennet (Hayden Panettiere), a small-town high school cheerleader who has a spontaneous regenerative ability (aka, "Save the Cheerleader. Save the World!"). And the hopelessly optimistic Hiro Nakamura (Masi Oka), a programmer from Tokyo with the ability to manipulate the space-time continuum -- and who is convinced that with other "special persons," he can be a hero and change the future.

Some of these heroes will have a harder time embracing their would-be gifts, however. There's D.L. Hawkins, the husband and father who can alter his physical tangibility and phase through solid objects, and whose estranged wife Niki (Ali Larter), an ex-stripper, will take refuge from her superhuman strength in an alternate personality. Their son Micah will also begin to exhibit the talents of a "technopath," allowing him to control machines and electronic devices, with potentially deadly consequences. Meanwhile, Nathan Petrelli (Adrian Pasdar) is a New York Congressional candidate who fears his ability of self-propelled flight could destroy his career, while his brother Peter Petrelli (Milo Ventimiglia), a former hospice nurse, struggles with his empathic powers to absorb and recall those who are near to him.

This first season of 'Heroes' (the hit show is due back on NBC for a second go-round beginning this September) is an origin tale. As such, there is a lot of explaining going on -- even more so in this HD DVD version, which features an extended version of the pilot and (if you're a true fan) over 50 deleted scenes. Even if you just watch the original episodes, there is much exposition to take in, and 'Heroes' can be a bit talky at first. Still, it's instantly captivating -- I was immediately drawn into the story, the mysteries of each character's superpowers, and the intricate plotting that lays the groundwork for engrossing intrigue to come. 'Heroes' may be sprawling in its aims, but it's so tightly produced that I was often left dazzled and amazed at the narrative land mines it navigates.

The serial nature of television allows 'Heroes' great latitude to explore the complexities of its characters in a way that would be impossible for a theatrical feature. The benefit is that it's almost impossible not to become emotionally wedded to their otherworldly predicamentd, and to root for their survival. From the initial realization of their superpowers in the pilot, through the physical hardships that are by turns hilarious and harrowing in subsequent episodes, 'Heroes' arguably digs deeper into the inner lives of its protagonists than any other serial currently on television -- and certainly any comic book movie ever made. 'Heroes' is just as intricately plotted as 'Smallville,' but far less reliant on the soap opera melodrama that can often be so formulaic on that show. Without being limited to a single superhero to explore, 'Heroes' also has a far more expansive range of character notes to hit -- and it never fails to surprise.

If I have any reservations about the show, it's that it doesn't have any big, flashy comic book villains, nor much action. Not that I need a silly pro-wrestler in tights, or a repetitive monster-of-the-week structure each episode. But there are times when 'Heroes' becomes so self-absorbed in the anxieties of its characters that it forgets to have fun, and teeters on the brink of being downright morose. Of course, 'Heroes' will never be -- not should it be -- camp. But a bit more humor would be welcome... because, after all, this is a group of superheroes we're talking about, not investment bankers.

Regardless, 'Heroes' is certainly the most exciting new show on television. And for having only been on one season, it's remarkable how quickly it has made inroads into becoming a mainstream phenomenon. There are enough water-cooler moments that it's the kind of show you feel compelled to watch, if only not be left out. This HD DVD set is certainly an excellent introduction to what all the buzz is about -- I was quickly drawn in, and I can't wait for season two.

The Video: Sizing Up the Picture

'Heroes' is not only one of the new breed of modern television shows produced in high-def from day one, but it also boasts production values that can at times rival that of any major Hollywood blockbuster. (Okay, so some of the CGI effects are cheesy -- but you try producing an hour-long show each week without a little cost-cutting here and there.) As you would expect, this HD DVD release is even more superior than the show's HD broadcast.

Each episode is presented in 1.78:1 widescreen and 1080p/VC-1 video, including the never-before-seen, recut 73-minute pilot. I was particularly impressed that in most aspects the source is quite consistent. Unlike 'Smallville,' which wears its comic book origins on its brightly-colored sleeves, at first glance 'Heroes' could easily be mistaken for a straightforward drama, with a realistic, less showy style of photography. Colors have a nice, deep richness without calling attention to themselves, and there is a noticeable use of filters (particularly blues during interiors, and acidic oranges on exteriors). Fleshtones hold firm fairly well, though occasionally the actors can look a bit sickly (perhaps that's intentional?)

Contrast is strong enough to lend a pleasing sense of depth to the image, and whites are for the most part not overly hot. Sharpness is also superior for a TV-based source, aside from a few of the CGI shots which suffer from an overload of motion blur (an apparent move to obscure the limitations of the show's budget). The transfers are a bit dark, however. Shadow delineation is not the absolute best I've seen, with fine details sometimes lost in the blacks.

However, by far the biggest irritant with these transfers is noise. Generally, the image looks smooth, but wide static shots are often laced with fuzziness -- especially large areas of white. Select slower shots can also look quite poor. For example, in the second episode on disc one, at around the 16 minute mark, there is a simple dialogue exchange that looks like it came from a different source -- noise is quite intense, and it's ugly. Such moments are scattered throughout the entire season, so get ready to be jarred out of the moment if you are particularly sensitive to video noise.

Otherwise, considering the sheer volume of material here, 'Heroes' is still quite good-looking, and generally impressive. It's definitely superior to the broadcasts I've seen, and fans will undoubtedly be pleased.

The Audio: Rating the Sound

Unfortunately, Universal has decided not to include high-resolution audio on 'Heroes,' so don't expect a Dolby TrueHD track or the like. Instead, we'll have to content ourselves with a mere Dolby Digital-Plus 5.1 surround track (at 1.5mbps). That said, the show's sound design isn't particularly dynamic anyway, so what we do get is perfectly serviceable audio.

As mentioned earlier, 'Heroes' is not particularly action-packed -- it's actually quite talky. Rare is an imitation of a 360-degree soundfield created -- and when it is, it doesn't last long. Discrete effects will pop up suddenly in the rears, be fairly loud, but then the track goes back to being front heavy. Spatiality is fair, with pans between channels not seamless, but certainly acceptable. Clarity and depth of range to the rears is also a bit too bright for my taste, as if the sound engineers were a bit too eager to make the rears more pronounced through sheer loudness.

Otherwise, dynamics are pretty strong. Dialogue is surprisingly well-recorded and consistent -- I rarely had trouble making out dialogue (an issue more common to TV releases). The subwoofer hits a few low tones, though it is not incredibly impactful. Again, high-end is a bit too forced and sometimes sounds a bit screechy. Finally, the score (by ex-Prince co-horts Lisa Coleman and Wendy Melvoin) is nicely rendered, but a bit subdued -- it certainly never stands out in the mix.

The Supplements: Digging Into the Good Stuff

Universal is bringing 'Heroes' to HD DVD day-and-date with its DVD debut, and mirroring the standard-def extras on each. Even if the HD DVD version didn't include a host of high-def exclusives, this would be quite package on its own -- there is a ton of great stuff here that fans are sure to devour.

Let's start with the 73-minute unaired Pilot on disc one. More than just a handful of extraneous scenes reinstated for marketing purposes, this is actually a recut version by series creator Tim Kring. The changes are quite substantial, if something a mixed bag. Much of it worked for me, including an entire subplot involving terrorists that adds palpable tension, and an entirely new introduction for the character Sylar (with an entirely different actor!). Other changes were less welcome, such as snips to the Petrelli family relationship that I missed. Those curious about this sometimes radically re-worked Pilot should turn to the optional audio commentary with Kring, who spends most of the track outlining the differences. He also is quite witty when it comes to discussing some of the budget limitations, including the majority of the sets being reused from "Crossing Jordan." Fun, informative stuff.

Less successful are the 50(!) Deleted Scenes scattered across remaining discs two through seven. Some are so short (literally seconds) that they comprise only mere lines of chopped dialogue. For the real gems, you've just gotta scour through it all -- there are some real nuggets here of character development, with a couple of subplots that I'm surprised were snipped. I won't spoil them, but die-hard fans will likely thrill to learn genuine new insights about their favorite show. Yes, watching 50 scenes is a commitment -- but then you bought a seven-disc box set promising hours of extras, didn't you?

Other video extras include five featurettes, all on disc seven. Truth be told, despite a decent combined length of about 45 minutes, these are rather surfacey in the end -- they certainly are no match for the breadth and depth of the dedicated picture-in-picture commentaries exclusive to the HD DVD release (see below).

The first featurette, 'The Making of 'Heroes'" (9 minutes) is your standard behind-the-scenes fluff piece. It touches on just the basics -- the concept, the casting, a quick overview of the production and hints at upcoming character arcs. There are the usual quick bits of production footage, and interviews with Kring and most of the main cast. Again, though, it's all a bit too superficial and slick to offer much beyond the promotional.

"Special Effects" (8 min.) offers another quick look at creating believable special effects for an hour-long weekly television series, and to say the time crunch is severe would be an understatement. Also interesting about this featurette is that a clear distinction is made between special effects (on-set trickery including rain, mood, etc.) and visual effects (stuff actually created on the computer).

"Stunts" (10 min.) is a continuation of the production detail. Featuring an interview with stunt coordinator Ian Quinn, he guides us through the basics, plus a few key action sequences.

The remaining two featurettes include "A Ppofile of Artist Tim Sale" (11 min.). A celebrated comic book artist, Sale's contribution to 'Heroes' is quite extensive, as he was in charge with largely conceptualizing the visual look of the show's protagonists. Basically a one-on-one chat, this one's arguably the most informative and fascinating of the featurettes on the disc.

Finally, "The Score" (9 min.) is cool, if only to seen what Wendy & Lisa have been up to all these years after the mega-success of 'Purple Rain' and the Prince & the Revolution phenomenon. Admittedly, I found their compositions to be a bit too well-integrated into the show, as they often seem to blend into nothingness. Still, it's great to see the composers of a TV show at last get some recognition.

Note that while the original unaired Pilot is in full 1080p/VC-1 video, (and looks just as good as the rest of the episodes), all of the other video extras listed above are presented in 480p/i/MPEG-2 video only (the deleted scenes are properly framed at 16:9, while the featurettes are windowboxed 4:3 only).

HD Bonus Content: Any Exclusive Goodies in There?

Universal has really loaded this one with a gaggle of exclusive content -- enough that it is probably the most packed high-def disc release I've yet seen, and it's certainly the most extensive U-control-enhanced title Universal has yet released.

I usually find the highlight of any HD DVD disc with exclusive content to be the picture-in-picture commentaries, and 'Heroes: Season 1' certainly doesn't disappoint in this category, offering up a series of tracks on eight different episodes -- "Godsend," "The Fix," "Distractions" (disc four); ".07%", "Five Years Game," "The Hard Part," "Landslide" (disc six); and "How to Stop an Exploding Man" (disc seven). Note that each track includes an almost completely different set of participants, from cast and crew, to creator Tim Kring (on "Exploding Head" only).

In the interest of time, I sampled about 15 minutes of each track. Each features its participants recorded as one big group with only a couple of cameras. There is no behind-the-scenes footage edited in like most PIP tracks, so these essentially function as audio commentaries, except you can now see the participants. That's something of a disappointment, as what's generally such a step up about PIP tracks is that they integrated disparate footage in a way that audio commentaries can't. Anyway, at least the detail is there, with each track almost non-stop with comments; and, depending on the groupings of the track, a general focus (the effects crew on one, the actors and writers on another, etc.)

Next up are a trio of interactive features all accessible via U-Control, and presented consistently on each episode across all seven discs.

Coolest is the Artwork Presentation. Throughout the season, the character of Isaac creates a series of paintings, some of which integrate into the plot (and much to fans' delight, the show's expanding mythology). Cleverly utilizing high-def technology in a way standard DVD could only dream of, here you can zoom in on any of the paintings for a closer look -- a very neat way of using interactivity to offer increased insight into a feature's narrative.

The disc's "Character Connections" feature is also unique. As the season progresses through each episode, you can "chart" the characters as they inter-connect. The map grows as the series soldiers on, and by the end it looks like a giant plate of spaghetti. Pretty nifty.

Finally, Helix Revealed is the one function I found completely superfluous. The Helix symbol proves integral to the growing complexity of the stories, and this finder will pinpoint its location for you as it pops up in each episode. I kept this function on throughout, hoping that after a while some cool thing would happen or a secret bonus feature would unlock -- so far, no luck. (But if I wake up tomorrow with a Helix symbol magically tattooed on my ass, I'm blaming you, Microsoft!)

Before we more on to the web-enabled features on the disc, note that there is also a "Mind Reader" interactive game rather tossed off on disc five. Here, you pick a number between 1 to 99, mark it to a specific hero on a grid, and then wait as the Matt Parkman character psychically guesses your choice. Quite honestly, I was bored with this one after about five minutes.

Capping off an already-impressive package are a couple of Internet-connect nuggets. Note that before you can utilize these features, you'll need to make sure that your HD DVD player's Ethernet connection is active, and you'll also need to register online (in one of two ways, either using your computer through Universal's web-based form, or directly via your player's remote).

Once that's done, the highlight is the Genetics Abilities Test. Answer a series of questions to "discover" if you too have advanced abilities. You can then save your profile and share it with other would-be heroes online.

There is also a second Download Center portal, though as of this writing, not much is up -- just a trailer for 'Heroes: Season One' and the upcoming Universal theatrical films 'Talk to Her' and 'White Noise 2' (which, presumably, will be making their way to HD DVD someday). However, promised future content include 'Heroes' polling allowing you to share your opinions with other fans online, an interface to organize your HD DVD player's online storage contents, and other material to be announced. We'll be looking forward to it...

Lastly, I must commend Universal for really getting their act together with this U-Control thing. Not only could other HD DVD-supporting studios take a few tips from Universal, but so could the Blu-ray camp -- I've yet to see a disc this user-friendly. Some of the niceties include a video tutorial on how to use the U-Control features, as well as the ability to adjust the volume of the PIP features and the main feature, so balance is never a problem. Universal has also indexed all of the U-Control features in the menu for each episode, so you can, for example, find the Helix symbols or other content right away without having to just sit there and wait. Finally, Universal provides its now-standard MyScenes feature, allowing you to mark your favorite segments (complete with custom starting and ending points) for instant access even after you eject the disc from the player. Very nicely done.

Final Thoughts

'Heroes' is television's breakout hit of the year, and for my money, it's just about the only TV comic book series that's ever been any good. Sure, it can be a bit slow-paced at times, and sometimes the characters' unending neurosis get a bit tiresome. But this is still genuinely compelling television, and I certainly will be tuning in for season two.

This HD DVD definitely impresses in the supplements department. Universal has packed in enough standard extras to keep any fan happy for days, plus a load of cutting-edge high-def exclusives that really push the boundaries of the format. Okay, so the video transfers can get a bit noisy at times and the audio is somewhat underwhelming, but as TV-on-high-def box sets go, this first season of 'Heroes' is now the one to beat.

Technical Specs

  • HD DVD
  • HD-30 Dual-Layer Discs
  • Seven-Disc Set

Video Resolution/Codec

  • 1080p/VC-1
  • 480p/i/MPEG-2 (Supplements Only)

Aspect Ratio(s)

  • 1.78:1

Audio Formats

  • English Dolby Digital-Plus 5.1 Surround (1.5mbps)

Subtitles/Captions

  • Englsh SDH
  • French Subtitles

Supplements

  • Unaired Extended Pilot Episode
  • Featurettes
  • Deleted Scenes

Exclusive HD Content

  • Picture-in-Picture Video Commentary
  • Character Connections
  • The Helix Revealed
  • Artwork Presentation
  • Download Center
  • Genetic Abilities Test

All disc reviews at High-Def Digest are completed using the best consumer HD home theater products currently on the market. More about our gear.

Puzzled by the technical jargon in our reviews, or wondering how we assess and rate HD DVD and Blu-ray discs? Learn about our review methodology.

Related reviews