HD DVD
Highly Recommended
4.5 stars
Amazon
$9.39
Usually ships in 24 hours Buy Now»
Overall Grade
4.5 stars

(click linked text below to jump to related section of the review)

The Movie Itself
4 Stars
HD Video Quality
4.5 Stars
HD Audio Quality
4.5 Stars
Supplements
2.5 Stars
High-Def Extras
2 Stars
Bottom Line
Highly Recommended

Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire

Street Date:
December 11th, 2007
Reviewed by:
High-Def Digest staff
Review Date: 1
December 17th, 2007
Movie Release Year:
2005
Studio:
Warner Home Video
Length:
157 Minutes
MPAA Rating:
Rated PG-13
Release Country
United States

Editor's Notes

Portions of this review also appear in our reviews of the domestic Blu-ray and the British HD DVD import.

The Movie Itself: Our Reviewer's Take

Harry Potter is more than everyone's favorite boy wizard -- he's a cultural phenomenon of unmatched proportions. The original book series by J. K. Rowling has sold over 325 million copies worldwide, spawning the film series, at least five video games and over 400 other Harry Potter-branded products. The film franchise itself ranks as highest grossing book-to-film series of all time, having earned (as of this writing) $3.5 billion worldwide, beating even The Lord of the Rings film trilogy (which has grossed $2.9 billion). If that's not magic, I don't know what is.

This fourth film in the series finds Harry (Daniel Radcliffe) inadvertently selected to be a competitor in the Tri-Wizard tournament, a dangerous competition usually reserved for older students. Challengers arrive from other academies across the globe, while budding love seems to spring up at every turn, with Harry, Hermione (Emma Watson), and Ron (Rupert Grint) all stumbling through the awkwardness of adolescence to sweet and sympathy-inducing results. But pulsing in the background is the ever-felt presence of evil on the rise. Conspirators have finally manipulated events to re-open the world to Voldemort -- a staple, unseen villain in the series, responsible for the deaths of Harry's parents and the scar across his forehead.

As always, the most engaging aspect of this fourth film in the series is the absolute pitch-perfect casting of each character. The actors all bring their own personalities to the table and deliver performances that capture the nuances and mild complexity of well-developed children's book characters. The three teenage leads ground themselves in realistic emotions, despite all of the underlying magical shenanigans. Each one rings true as a teen lost in a world where they're unable to express their feelings for fear of rejection. The supporting cast is also top notch, although most of the players appear to hit one note in the plot before being whisked off into the background. For people who haven't seen the other films, the barrage of literally hundreds of characters may be daunting, as the pace of the film doesn't leave much room for introductions or recaps.

Thematically, the kids at Hogwarts have certainly grown up. There's a cynicism and foreboding doom hovering over every head, which really helps to build pressure in the plot. Voldemort is such an impending black hole in every character's life that his eventual appearance is seeped with an impressive sense of doom. Of course, the excellent Ralph Fiennes has a big hand in this, managing to craft a fierce hatred behind his bulging eyes.

Overall, I enjoyed the dark tone of this film -- it certainly makes the series a bit more accessible for adult audiences. But like 'Prisoner of Azkaban,' it doesn't mesh perfectly with the film's more kiddie-fare elements. For every tense moment where Harry fights a dragon or a swarm of underwater creatures, there's a counter-moment with comical glimpses of image-shifting badges, colorful smoke trails, and slapstick consequences to the misuse of magic. I understand these are key components of this fictional universe and fan favorite scenes from the books, but the result is a film that feels conflicted about its identity. It retains the things that made the earlier installments soft and whimsical, but adds in so much darkness that there seem to be two completely different tones fighting for dominance.

Having said that, I loved the Tri-Wizard tournament scenes (the horntail, the demonic mermaids, the hedge maze), quieter developments with Harry's awkward pursuit of love, and the sudden encounter with Voldemort. I was enthralled when Harry was put through the paces, and I found myself leaning forward whenever the film drifted away from dances, popularity contests, and high school antics. There's a kinetic energy to the emotionally and physically harsh moments, and happily for me, these are more prevalent in 'Goblet of Fire' than ever before.

In short, 'Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire' is my favorite installment in the series -- there are some amazing scenes here that truly thrilled me. And while I found the film's inconsistent themes and lack of focus distracting at times, fans of the series will likely vibrate in their seats at every turn as they enjoy its particular blend of darkness and whimsy.

The Video: Sizing Up the Picture

The HD DVD edition of 'Goblet of Fire' is presented with a crisp 1080p/VC-1 transfer (identical to the Blu-ray) that showcases every pebble and crack the film has to offer. While it isn't quite as jaw-dropping as ' Order of the Phoenix,' it looks a hair better than 'Prisoner of Azkaban,' tops 'Chamber of Secrets,' and easily outclasses 'Sorcerer's Stone.' By further comparison, it makes the standard-def 'Goblet of Fire' DVD an absolute waste of shelf space.

Black levels are solid, colors are vibrant, texture detail is astounding, and the naturalistic CG creations are gorgeous. One look at a scene like Dumbledore's opening speech will leave you marveling at the tiny candles, the intricate weaving of the costumes, and the elemental detailing of rain, stars, and rocks. Then there's the battle with the horntail dragon, where leathery wings, crumbling stone, wood and rock at the base of the stadium are all on vibrant display -- I could go on and on for pages just talking about the technical treats in this scene alone.

The source is pristine -- there's no artifacting, noise, or problematic crush visible. Some of the film's more colorful CG looks a bit more artificial in high-def than it does in standard definition, but I was surprised to find that other CG effects actually looked more believable. The horntail, the underwater squid creatures, and the exterior shots of the school have a big impact and inject a welcome earthiness into the illusion. Shots of Hogwarts look phenomenal (especially the long tracking shot leading to the Owlery tower) -- if you so desired, you could count every brick on every building.

Earlier this year, I had the chance to review the UK import HD DVD (which was originally released in November of 2006), where I complained about clarity and contrast inconsistencies that appeared in a few major scenes. While I no longer have the UK disc on hand to do a side-by-side comparison, this release appears to fix the majority of the problems I had with the import. Darker scenes are still a bit soft compared to brighter exterior shots, but it's a negligible difference that doesn't undermine the showcase scenes in the transfer. All in all, 'Goblet of Fire' looks remarkable in its stateside high-def debut, falling just shy of a five-star video rating.

The Audio: Rating the Sound

Warner Home Video has really stepped up its game in the audio department with its 'Harry Potter' high-def releases. While the majority of the studio's previous HD DVD discs have only had standard Dolby Digital Plus tracks (at 640 kbps), each entry in the 'Potter' series features what amounts to a staggering upgrade. Hitting the sound-for-sound intensity of 'Order of the Phoenix,' 'Goblet of Fire' includes a powerful Dolby TrueHD 5.1 surround track (48 kHz/16-Bit/1.8 Mbps) that makes Harry's trials sound more treacherous than ever.

It doesn't take a trained ear to notice the deep bass, crisp dialogue, and the other immersive qualities of this TrueHD mix. The effects and music are nicely prioritized throughout each channel -- the rear speakers are brimming with activity, adding subtle ambiance to quiet scenes, and chaotic clutter to the more tense battle scenes. More importantly, an aggressive LFE presence keeps the track dynamic with booming bass tones that hit me in the chest before my ears even registered the impact. Between the lush score, the constant barrage of magic blasts, and shouts from every character, the soundfield could easily be feel crowded, but the sound designers meld everything together as it should be and I never lost a line of dialogue -- even when characters were barely whispering. For a movie boasting such fantastical heights, the sound package helps to ground each effect so things are never reminiscent of an over-the-top video game.

The one thing that keeps 'Goblet of Fire' from reaching the audible heights of 'Order of the Phoenix' is a pesky leveling issue. In scenes like the horntail battle, everything rings at the same volume -- crashing rocks, flapping wings, and the roar of the dragon are blared from every channel. The effect is meant to stir the listener, but the increased response to the noise comes at the expense of authenticity. This all-encompassing peak level isn't a technical fault -- I have no desire to hear things at their actual volume in comparison to dialogue -- but the end result in 'Goblet of Fire' feels a bit unimaginative. In other fantasy films like 'Lord of the Rings' and the 'Star Wars' prequels, the designers allow heavy moments to rest on the shoulders of the subwoofer so vibration provides as much impact as multi-channel volume. It's a minor nitpick to be sure, but one I noticed regardless.

All, quibbles aside, fans will be extremely pleased to hear how good 'Goblet of Fire' sounds on this high definition release. This HD DVD disc continues to put the technical presentation of the standard DVD to shame.

The Supplements: Digging Into the Good Stuff

Warner may have brought out the big guns with the audio and video on this HD DVD edition of 'Goblet of Fire,', but the supplemental package offers no such upgrades, simply porting over all of the supplements (minus an interactive trivia game and a videogame trailer) that appeared on the Special Edition DVD. The making-of material is divided into eight well-organized sections that avoid repetition and cover everything a fan could want to know.

  • Conversations with the Cast (HD, 31 minutes) -- This lone documentary is actually a lengthy fireside conversation with Radcliffe, Watson, and Grint hosted by Richard Curtis, the writer of 'Notting Hill' and 'Four Weddings and a Funeral.' While the last ten minutes is limited to simple wish fulfillment as contest-winning fans join the interview and ask the leads a few questions, the first twenty minutes is a strong discussion with each of the young actors. Watson speaks the most, Radcliffe seems shy but the most professional of the trio, while Grint largely sits on the sideline and agrees. I was amused by how much the actors resembled their characters in this regard, but the questions are top notch and the responses are thoughtful. It's also the only material presented in full 1080p and anamorphic widescreen.
  • Meet the Champions (SD, 13 minutes) -- This solid actor and character featurette is both funny and candid. It follows a typical morning for a supporting actor from the moment they wake up until they hit the set in full costume. Off-the-cuff interviews and fly-on-the-wall behind-the-scenes footage make this one an amusing watch.
  • Reflections on the Fourth Film -- (SD, 13 minutes) This featurette lightens the mood with a look back through the series that features plenty of footage of the actors when they were soft-faced children working on 'Sorcerer's Stone.' This one packs quite a lot under the hood as it allows the teens to look back at where they've come from. A fitting companion piece to Curtis's interview, it pulls the camera back into a wider view of the series as a whole.
  • He Who Must Not Be Named (SD, 11 minutes) -- This segment tracks an average day for actor Ralph Fiennes. The camera follows him from the make-up chair to the set as he crafts his focused portrayal of Voldemort. His comments and the design work for the character's look are engaging and push this featurette into a higher league.
  • Harry vs. the Horntail (SD, 6 minutes) -- This featurette covers the design and implementation of the CG dragon as well as the scene in which Potter battles it for a golden egg. This standard creature featurette is an easy watch, but it's somewhat burdened by the familiarity of its information.
  • In Too Deep (SD, 9 minutes) -- Much more interesting than its predecessor, this short details CG environment creation as it pertained to the aquatic challenge. It examines the combination of practical water-tank shots and a CG underwater world without ever getting numbingly technical.
  • The Maze (SD, 7 minutes) -- This quick hit is largely focused on practical effects and their ability to bring out more convincing reactions in the cast members. I was impressed to see that the living hedges were built to scale and controlled by hand, but again this presentation suffers from a been-there-done-that familiarity.
  • Preparing for the Yule Ball (SD, 9 minutes) -- An annoying, throw-away addition showcasing the family atmosphere and fun of the shoot. It never feels as if it has too much of a point and only serves as a glimpse at how much the teenage cast enjoyed their time on the film.
  • Deleted Scenes (SD, 10 minutes) -- This collection of eight, low-def cuts is a minor disappointment full of repetitive plot clarification, disjointed romantic interludes, and a horrid number of eye-rolling songs. The worst of the bunch is also the longest -- a scene in which an aging and awkward rock band plays at the Hogwarts dance. Straight out of a different film, it's both painful and hilarious at the same time. If this scene had been left in the film it would've brought my experience to a screeching halt.
  • Theatrical Trailer (SD, 2 minutes)

HD Bonus Content: Any Exclusive Goodies in There?

In addition to standard extras outlined above, this HD DVD release also gets a nice exclusive that's not included on either on the Blu-ray edition or any of the standard DVDs. Activate the "In-Movie Experience" (IME) to watch various picture-in-picture interviews, behind-the-scenes footage and other making-of material in real-time along with the movie.

While I was pleased by the lack of repetition on this IME, it has a few gaps between the content bits -- surely there must be piles upon piles of design sketches, concept art, and set plans that could've filled the void. When it is active however, the track is informative, featuring engaging chats with cast and crew, and examining the shooting of the film from beginning to end.

The lone annoyance is the odd inclusion of commentary bits with James and Oliver Phelps, the actors who play the eldest Weasley brothers. Their attempts at humor often fall flat and they're never serious enough to add anything very interesting to the proceedings. Actors higher up in the character hierarchy would've been much more welcome. While fun commentaries worked with the hobbit actors on 'The Lord of the Rings' extended edition DVDs, it was because other substantial commentaries were available for more serious discussions. I did appreciate the visual elements used during their commentary (things like on screen countdowns and circles around key things being referenced), but at times it felt more like an episode of "Blind Date" than a clever use of the technique.

There's also a quick-reference "Timeline" included that charts out the events of the Potter films. This is certainly an odd and uncompelling exclusive, but it's an exclusive feature nonetheless.

Final Thoughts

'Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire' is another fine high-def release in the fan-favorite series. The film itself is easily my favorite of the 'Potter' films and I enjoyed watching it again. This high-def edition of the flick boasts a stunning transfer, a bold TrueHD mix and a decent collection of supplements. Even better, Warner has included an exclusive "In-Movie Experience" that's exclusive to this HD DVD edition, giving it a leg up on its Blu-ray counterpart. An easy recommend all around.

Technical Specs

  • HD DVD
  • HD-30 Dual-Layer Disc

Video Resolution/Codec

  • 1080p/VC-1

Aspect Ratio(s)

  • 2.40:1

Audio Formats

  • English Dolby TrueHD 5.1 Surround (48kHz/16-Bit/1.8Mbps)
  • English Dolby Digital-Plus 5.1 Surround
  • French Dolby Digital-Plus 5.1 Surround
  • Spanish Dolby Digital-Plus 5.1 Surround

Subtitles/Captions

  • English Subtitles
  • French Subtitles
  • Spanish Subtitles

Supplements

  • Documentary
  • Featurettes
  • Deleted Scenes
  • Theatrical Trailer

Exclusive HD Content

  • In-Movie Experience
  • Timeline

All disc reviews at High-Def Digest are completed using the best consumer HD home theater products currently on the market. More about our gear.

Puzzled by the technical jargon in our reviews, or wondering how we assess and rate HD DVD and Blu-ray discs? Learn about our review methodology.

Amazon
$9.39
Usually ships in 24 hours Buy Now»